JUDGING EXPLAINED by Duane Wilson
Another year of judging cars for the CVR club has passed by. I had a lot of nice weather to check out a total of fifty-one of your cars from twenty-two classes. It was a real treat to critique your beautiful and unique automobiles. Special thanks goes out to those of you who gave me insight on a particular model or year. I apologize if your vehicle was missed for judging due to one reason or another.
I’d like to give some details on how I go about judging your vehicles. The judging sheet which is our bible has all the criteria on it. By now you should have received yours in the mail with scores from last year’s review. Judging involves many categories such as body and sheet metal, interior, engine, undercarriage, bright work, engine and exhaust system, drive train as well as electrical. For all the classes except modified, authenticity is a factor except in the last three areas noted. It all starts as if the car was a perfect one hundred point car and points are deducted from there. It is always helpful when everything can be viewed without obstruction. Vehicles may loose points for a closed hood or if it has a seat with a blanket on it compared to one that is has all areas showing in open view. For final tallies at the end of a year, a few tenths of a point between vehicles can make the difference of where it places.
On the body itself, I’m looking for misaligned body panels, scratches, dents, rust and a compromised paint finish. Points are deducted not only if they are present but also on the degree of their severity. Weather plays a big role in this as a sunny day can bring out imperfections that you didn’t know you had. Cloudy and dark days may hide small dents, wavy panels and imperfections in the finish. This sometimes can be a big challenge for me when judging.
The condition and authenticity of the automobiles underside gets scored in the chassis section. This includes everything from rust on the frame and floorboards to leaks from the engine, transmission, and rear end. On most vehicles this is the area that gets the least attention to detail when detailing is done. This is understandable as most of these cars are drivers. For me, this is one of the most undesirable places to judge.
I believe the engine compartment is the second most overlooked part of the car as it is the hardest part to detail because of the obstacles you have to work around. When judging this area, the condition and authenticity are considered for scoring. I judge on the degree of “crispness” and cleanliness. Aftermarket parts must be noted and deducted from the points for all but the modified class. Again, please note that it is important that the compartment is available to view-either by having the hood up or at least having it ajar so I can peek inside. Otherwise, I give a standard equal score. Thus, anyone with a viewable compartment usually fairs much better in this category.
Plating and bright work is another judging category. Grills, bumpers, door handles, mirrors, emblems, moldings, lanterns and radiators are among the parts that get looked at. Chrome, brass or pewter in nice condition can do so much for a vehicle as it accents the body. Although this category isn’t rated high in the point scale, it still is an important category because every point adds up.
The interior section is awarded double the point potential as compared to bright work. I check for faded or ripped headliner, carpet, or seats, and missing parts, pitted chrome and quality of paint finish. Seats that are mostly covered with blankets, etc. are assumed to be ripped or faded. I usually spend some time looking at the dash and steering column. There is nothing I like better than a nice looking instrument panel. Cleanliness is nice but I realize most of these cars are drivers so surface dirt is somewhat expected.
The next three scored areas are those that do not have authenticity considered. Per judging guidelines, your car needs to be running when the engine and exhaust grouping are critiqued. I assume these to be in top condition unless I particularly find them not to be such as I notice excessive noise or smoke. Drive train is a self-explanatory category. I mainly assume the status of wheels, tires, axles, safety of brakes and steering to be in good working order. The last scored section, electrical and accessories, is only awarded a maximum of five points. I just assess the condition of these with a quick review.
A few years ago the club officers decided to add a lot more classes for vehicles to potentially be categorized in. We now have a total of 29 classes available. By having this many, the club has done an outstanding job to ensure that each member can belong to a class that fits their vehicle well.
I look forward to the dust off meet to start the 2007 judging year. I await this time to see the changes your vehicles may have undergone during the winter months. Maybe even some vehicles we have never had the opportunity to view will be rolled out. The excitement builds!
See you soon with my trusty judging notebook in hand.